Timothy McSweeney's Header Image

M O R E   C A S E S   F R O M
T H E   F I L E S   O F
T R A I G   &   M c G R A T H ,
S H U T - I N   D E T E C T I V E S .


BY JENNY TRAIG AND PETER McGRATH


- - - -

Some time ago, Peter McGrath and Jenny Traig, cousins, left their jobs to become self-declared shut-ins. They quickly discovered that even the shut-in's life is full of social encounters and mysteries, and no mystery is greater than that of the human heart. Here, for the edification of their readers, is a selection from their Social Life files.

- - - -

[Read previous case files: #1–5, #6–9, and #10–13.]

- - - -

#14: The Case of the Sabotaged Taping
Status: Suspended

With plans to catch up on several hours of Must-see TV, Peter and Jenny seated themselves in front of the television and popped a tape into the VCR. Instead of canned laughter and wacky high jinks, the tape contained six hours of the Weather Channel. How had that happened? So started another mystery for the Shut-In detectives.

Peter and Jenny considered several scenarios. Jenny suggested a power failure. Peter suspected a break-in. "Or perhaps," Jenny wondered, "you blacked out on the couch with the VCR remote under your backside and accidentally pressed 'record,' as you've done several times before." Peter countered that this was unlikely, as he only passed out after eating carbs, which he had not done that day.

Two possibilities remained: 1) Peter was lying about the carbs; or 2) Somebody was attempting to send the detectives secret encoded messages through the television. The investigation was suspended when Peter and Jenny decided they would rather watch the weather tape than solve their mystery. It proved remarkably soothing and soon the detectives were fast asleep, the remote safely on the coffee table, where it belongs.

- - - -

#15: The Case of the Hombre Mysterioso
Status: Solucionado

One evening Peter and Jenny were practicing their synchronized dance routine when their roommate Angela interrupted. "I just got another call for 'Humberto,'" she stormed. "That's like the hundredth time this year. Who is Humberto, and why do I keep getting his calls? By the way, you two look like jerks."

The dancing sleuths had another mystery on their hands. Squeezing a reluctant Angela in the middle of their funk sandwich, they began their questioning.

"Do you get these calls during the day, or at night?"

"Both," Angela answered.

"Do the callers sound attractive?"

"How would I know?"

"Do they ever ask what you're wearing?"

"No. What kind of questions are these?"

"Is there anything else you can tell us?"

"Yes. Humberto gets more calls than I do. I gave my phone number to two men last week, and the only call I got was from my alumni association."

"That's it!" Peter cried. "My dear, you've solved your own mystery. Obviously, when you're out in the bars, giving your number to anything in pants, you are so drunk that you forget your own name. You must be introducing yourself as Humberto. These mysterious calls are, in fact, for you."

Angela protested that she is a teetotaler, and that the gentlemen recipients of her phone number were, in fact, co-workers, but the detectives concluded these objections were lies. The cousins further concluded that Angela was lying about their routine looking stupid, because they are really, really good dancers.

- - - -

#16: The Case of the Ambiguous Complexion OR What Season is Peter?
Status: Solved

Recently the Shut-Ins invited a few close friends over for an evening of card games and refreshments. Peter wanted to look his best. There was one question: What should he wear?

Jenny recommended his long-sleeved olive T-shirt, because it complements his coloring. Peter disagreed. "Olive makes me look sallow. But my baby blue polo shirt will bring out my eyes." "Don't be silly," Jenny returned. "Blue washes you out. You're a classic fall." Peter shook his head. "I'm a summer. However, my sister insists I'm a spring."

The cousins realized they had another mystery on their hands. They immediately set to work, holding fabric swatches up to Peter's face. He looked equally good in the cool teal tones of the summer palette, the coral hues of spring, and the warm golds of fall. When the swatching failed to narrow the field, the detectives daubed Peter's face with makeup. Still, no clear season emerged.

It was time to consult the textbook. There they read that summers are calm and delicate, falls complicated and mysterious, and springs fanciful and fun-loving.

The mystery was solved. Peter was a spring. But he decided to wear the fall olive shirt because it hides stains well. He also wore a little makeup, because everyone likes to feel pretty.

- - - -

#17: The Case of the Big Night Out
Status: Solved

One recent evening the Shut-Ins were prevailed upon to join their friend Mr. G— in a rare night on the town. Halfway through a screening of Dude, Where's My Car?, Mr. G— disappeared. Where had he gone? The detectives set to work.

"Could it be," Peter asked sotto voce, "that Mr. G— left because he could take no more of the intoxicated young lady in the fifth row, who is now conducting her fourth cell phone conversation? The subject of which is, yet again, the fact that she is in a movie theater."

Jenny thought it was more likely that Mr. G— left because he could take no more of the same young lady yelling, "Dude, where's my car?" every five minutes.

At this point the investigation was suspended, because the movie became extremely compelling. Twenty minutes later, the mystery was solved when Peter, answering nature's call, found a food-poisoned but otherwise sound Mr. G— lying on the floor of the men's room. Peter stepped over his fallen comrade and returned to the theater, whereupon he and Jenny loudly offered possible solutions to the far more entertaining mystery of the titular car's location.

- - - -

#18: The Case of the Uninvited Visitors
Status: Solved

Peter and Jenny were awakened one weekday morning by their doorbell. When Jenny looked out the front window, she saw a pair of neatly-groomed young men in dark suits.

"Don't answer it," warned Peter, rubbing his eyes. "It's much too early to be defending ourselves against ruffians. If we stay very quiet, they will surely depart."

And so the detectives chose prudence over curiosity, and returned to their beds. When they awoke several hours later, the detectives discussed the identity of their mysterious visitors. Jenny concluded that since they were wearing black they might be entertainers, or perhaps publicists. And if they were, in fact, "in the biz," might they be in a cult? But which cult?

The detectives immediately ruled out Scientology and est, because the young men didn't look very self-actualized. They couldn't be Satanists, because they weren't eating babies. The lack of literature left on the doorstep left the detectives befuddled. Who were these mysterious guests?

The solution, it turned out, was obvious. "My dear, we've overlooked the most glaring clue," Peter announced. "Our mysterious visitors rang the doorbell at 8 AM. Only one sort of person would do that: an asshole. Identity discovered. Mystery solved. Case closed." And with that, our intrepid sleuths retreated to their rooms for a well-deserved and much-needed nap.

- - - -

The Shut-In detectives invite readers to submit their mysteries to shutindetectives@hotmail.com. The Shut-Ins will do their best to solve them.

 

 

OTHER McSWEENEY'S STORIES:
- - - -


Excerpts From My Speech on Forest Fire Prevention (Reprinted from February 22, 1999) By Arthur Bradford
More History's Notable Persons Reconsidered By Tim Carvell
Rounder Characters in No Time Flat By John Warner
Rites of Spring Vacation By Anthony Mascorro
Unused Audio Commentary By Dinesh D'Souza and Ann Coulter, Recorded Spring 2003, for Aliens Special Red-State Edition DVD, Part Two By Jeff Alexander and Tom Bissell

- - - -

MAIN PAGE   |   ARCHIVES

 

Memories of Amanda Davis

 


Red dot denotes content that is new today.

Black dot denotes newish content.

McSWEENEY'S STORE

SUBSCRIBE TO:
McSWEENEY'S
THE BELIEVER
WHOLPHIN

FUTURE McSWEENEY'S BOOKS

THE AMANDA DAVIS HIGHWIRE FICTION AWARD

INVITE A McSWEENEY'S AUTHOR TO SPEAK IN YOUR TOWN OR COLLEGE

McSWEENEY'S MONTHLY MAILING LIST

McSWEENEY'S-RELATED EVENTS AND VARIOUS TOUR DATES

ORDER INQUIRIES AND ADDRESS CHANGES

SUBMISSION GUIDELINES:
FOR BOOKS
FOR THE QUARTERLY
FOR THE WEBSITE
FOR WHOLPHIN

McSWEENEY'S INTERNSHIPS

CONTACT US

- - - -

LETTERS TO McSWEENEY'S

LISTS

McSWEENEY'S PREDICTS

McSWEENEY'S RECOMMENDS

NEW WHOLPHIN FILM

DAN LIEBERT, VERBAL CARTOONIST

JOKES BY BRIAN BEATTY

REVIEWS OF NEW FOOD

DISPATCHES FROM MOSCOW

SO YOU WANT TO BE PRESIDENT?

DISPATCHES FROM THE ANACOSTIA

THE WINNER'S CIRCLE WITH ERIC FEEZELL

BEN GREENMAN'S FAKE CELEBRITY MUSICALS

DISPATCHES FROM A HUMANITARIAN JOURNALIST

DISPATCHES FROM IRAQ

SHORT IMAGINED MONOLOGUES

PHILIP GRAHAM SPENDS A YEAR IN LISBON

STAINED TEETH: A COLUMN ABOUT WINE

DISPATCHES FROM THE NAPOLEONIC WARS AT THE MET

KEVIN DOLGIN TELLS YOU ABOUT PLACES YOU SHOULD GO IN EUROPE

SONGS OF ENEMIES AND DESERTS: LIVING WITH THE SUDAN LIBERATION ARMY

LAWRENCE WESCHLER'S EVERYTHING THAT RISES: A BOOK OF CONVERGENCES

THE CONVERGENCES CONTEST

ABOUT WHAT IS THE WHAT

ABOUT BOWL OF CHERRIES

ABOUT COMEDY BY THE NUMBERS

ABOUT JOHN BRANDON'S ARKANSAS

LETTERS FROM AN EARTH BALL TO, OR CONCERNING, SEAN HANNITY

DISPATCHES FROM ADJUNCT FACULTY AT A LARGE STATE UNIVERSITY

ADVICE FROM A PERSON WITH A BACHELOR'S DEGREE IN PSYCHOLOGY

DISPATCHES FROM THE NBA ENTERTAINMENT LEAGUE

JOHN MOE'S POP-SONG CORRESPONDENCES

B.R. COHEN'S ANNALS OF SCIENCE

INTERVIEWS WITH PEOPLE WHO HAVE INTERESTING OR UNUSUAL JOBS

OPEN LETTERS TO PEOPLE OR ENTITIES WHO ARE UNLIKELY TO RESPOND

DISPATCHES FROM A PUBLIC LIBRARIAN

MICHAEL IAN BLACK IS A VERY FAMOUS CELEBRITY

DISPATCHES FROM ROY KESEY, AN AMERICAN GUY MARRIED TO
A PERUVIAN DIPLOMAT LIVING IN CHINA


STEPHEN ELLIOTT'S POKER REPORT

- - - -

ADDITIONAL MATERIAL